Document type: Checklist Practice area: Corporate — Securities and Disclosure Jurisdiction: United States (federal and state) and European Union Last reviewed: 5 September 2026
How to use this checklist
Section 1 determines scope and should be completed before any other work. Sections 2 through 5 build the substance. Sections 6 through 8 are controls, review, and the recurring cycle.
Items marked [LIABILITY] are the ones that most often turn into a claim.
1. Obligation map
- Public securities of any kind identified (equity, debt, continuing disclosure undertakings) — if any, all public statements are subject to the antifraud provisions of 15 U.S.C. § 78j and, for registered offerings, 15 U.S.C. § 77k. [LIABILITY]
- Total revenue and California-attributable revenue determined against the California statutory thresholds — applies whether or not the company is public. [LIABILITY]
- EU entities, branches, and EU turnover assessed against CSRD scoping, including non-EU parent phase-in.
- Other national regimes assessed (United Kingdom, Japan, Australia, Canada, Singapore).
- Credit agreements reviewed for sustainability-linked KPIs, definitions, and certification deadlines. [LIABILITY]
- Customer contracts and supplier codes reviewed for reporting obligations, reduction commitments, and audit rights.
- All live environmental marketing claims inventoried — packaging, website, sales materials, trade show collateral. [LIABILITY]
- One-page obligation map produced listing regime, trigger, deliverable, first due date, and owner.
- Map reviewed and refreshed annually.
2. Governance
- A single accountable owner named for all sustainability disclosure — report, website, packaging, questionnaires, customer templates, credit certifications, and regulatory filings. [LIABILITY]
- Board committee charter names sustainability disclosure oversight.
- Committee reporting cadence set; minutes reflect substantive engagement.
- Sustainability disclosure added to the disclosure committee agenda.
- Data ownership assigned by category, each with a named owner, source system, and extraction method.
- Legal review established as a publication gate for every public sustainability statement. [LIABILITY]
- Escalation path defined for discovered errors and for claims that cannot be substantiated.
3. Greenhouse gas inventory — boundary and base year
- Organizational boundary selected (equity share / financial control / operational control), with reasoning documented.
- Boundary disclosed and applied consistently across all reporting.
- Operational boundary listed: every facility, fleet, and emissions source.
- Joint ventures, minority stakes, and leased assets addressed explicitly.
- Base year selected and justified.
- Base year recalculation policy written — threshold, trigger events (acquisition, divestiture, structural change, methodology change), approver, and disclosure requirement. [LIABILITY]
- Policy written before the next transaction, not after.
4. Scope 1, 2, and 3
Scope 1
- Stationary combustion: natural gas, propane, fuel oil, biomass — from invoices and fuel records.
- Mobile combustion: owned and leased vehicles — from fuel cards, fleet systems, or mileage by class.
- Process emissions from chemical or physical processes.
- Fugitive emissions from refrigerants — from purchase and service records. Routinely omitted.
Scope 2
- Location-based figure computed using regional grid factors.
- Market-based figure computed using contractual instruments and residual mix.
- Both figures reported. [LIABILITY]
- Every contractual instrument documented: quantity, vintage, technology, geography, registry, and retirement evidence.
- Certificates purchased but not retired excluded from the market-based figure.
Scope 3
- All fifteen categories screened; significant categories identified and documented.
- Method selected and documented per category (spend-based / average-data / supplier-specific / hybrid).
- Supplier data program established for the largest categories, with template, deadline, follow-up, and procurement escalation.
- Coverage percentage computed: proportion of the figure that is supplier-specific versus estimated.
- Uncertainty range computed and disclosed. [LIABILITY]
- The word "estimated" used wherever the figure was estimated — not "measured." [LIABILITY]
Emissions factors
- Factor library maintained with source, version, publication date, and units for every factor.
- Factor updates identified and their effect quantified separately from changes in activity.
5. Targets, transition plan, and offsets
- Base year inventory established before any target announcement.
- Levers identified with estimated contribution, cost, and timing.
- Achievable reduction summed and compared to the proposed target.
- The gap quantified and recorded. [LIABILITY]
- Dependencies for closing the gap identified explicitly (grid decarbonization, future technology, offsets).
- Capital plan confirmed consistent with the levers.
- Board committee approval on a record that includes the analysis, not a summary.
- Public target disclosure describes levers, contributions, gap, and dependencies — not only the number. [LIABILITY]
- Interim milestones stated and tracked.
- Transition plan describes actions, timing, capital, and accountability.
- Offsets, if used, disclosed separately from gross emissions, with quantity, vintage, project type, registry, verification standard, and retirement evidence. [LIABILITY]
- No unqualified "carbon neutral," "net zero," "climate positive," or "sustainable" claim at the product level. [LIABILITY]
- Offset additionality, permanence, leakage, double counting, and vintage assessed and documented.
6. Risk assessment and securities disclosure
- Financial materiality assessed under TSC Industries, Inc. v. Northway, Inc., 426 U.S. 438 (1976) and, for contingencies, Basic Inc. v. Levinson, 485 U.S. 224 (1988).
- Impact materiality assessed with a documented process if CSRD applies (double materiality).
- Physical risk assessed facility by facility: hazards, exposure, business interruption, insurance availability and cost trend, mitigation.
- Transition risk assessed: policy, technology, market, reputation.
- Material climate matters reflected in risk factors, MD&A, business description, and legal proceedings under Regulation S-K, 17 C.F.R. Part 229.
- Risk factors checked against realized events — no hypothetical framing of a risk that has already materialized. [LIABILITY]
- MD&A addresses climate matters with material effect on results, liquidity, or capital resources.
- Loss contingency accounting applied to climate-related litigation and enforcement.
7. Environmental marketing claims
- Every live claim identified across packaging, website, sales materials, and social channels.
- Substantiation file assembled for each claim before it runs, per the FTC Green Guides, 16 C.F.R. Part 260. [LIABILITY]
- General claims ("green," "eco-friendly," "sustainable") qualified or removed.
- Claim scope specified: product, package, or component.
- Recyclability claims tested against actual municipal acceptance.
- Recycled content, degradability, and compostability claims substantiated.
- Renewable energy and renewable materials claims substantiated with retirement evidence.
- "Free of" claims verified.
- Competitor exposure under 15 U.S.C. § 1125 considered for each comparative or superiority claim. [LIABILITY]
- State consumer protection exposure considered for consumer-facing claims.
- New claim approval gate established with legal review.
8. Data controls
- Version-controlled calculation workbook with locked formulas and a change log. [LIABILITY]
- Documented methodology that a person who did not build the workbook can follow.
- Every input traceable to a source document, retained.
- Reconciliations run: fuel emissions to fuel expense; electricity to utility invoices and metered consumption; travel to booking system; waste to hauler invoices; procurement spend to general ledger.
- Preparer and reviewer are different people; review documented.
- Change management policy covering methodology, boundary, factor updates, base year recalculation, and restatement — with thresholds, approvals, and disclosure requirements.
- Carbon accounting platform evaluated once the inventory stabilizes.
9. Assurance
- Readiness assessment run one full year before assurance is required.
- Readiness findings remediated and remediation documented.
- Assurance provider engaged; scope and standard confirmed.
- Limited versus reasonable assurance understood and correctly described in the disclosure.
- Disclosure does not imply that limited assurance verifies accuracy or converts an estimate into a measurement. [LIABILITY]
- Assurance findings treated as a work plan and tracked to closure.
10. Review before publication
- Substantiation file complete: workbook, evidence, methodology, factor library, reconciliations, target analysis with gap, offset documentation, assurance report, and support for every claim.
- Every quantitative statement traced to the workbook.
- Every qualitative claim traced to support.
- Every superlative and comparative challenged.
- Every instance of "measured" verified.
- Four recurring errors specifically checked: estimate described as measurement; unqualified neutrality claim; market-based Scope 2 without location-based; target without basis or gap. [LIABILITY]
- All sustainability communications read side by side by one person for inconsistency: report, periodic filings under 15 U.S.C. § 78m, CSRD report, credit certification, customer templates, website.
- Bridge schedules prepared explaining every difference between reported figures.
- Disclosure committee sign-off recorded.
- Substantiation file archived as of the publication date.
11. Recurring cycle
- Data collection close and workbook preparation — Q1.
- Reconciliations and reviewer sign-off — Q1.
- Credit agreement KPI certification computed and delivered — per agreement. [LIABILITY]
- Assurance engagement — Q2.
- Materiality assessment refreshed — Q2.
- Physical and transition risk refreshed — Q2.
- Target progress computed; gap re-analyzed — Q2.
- Report drafted and legally reviewed — Q3.
- Website environmental claim sweep — Q3. [LIABILITY]
- Board committee review — Q3.
- Publication with sign-off recorded — Q3.
- Customer templates and ratings questionnaires routed through legal review — Q4.
- Questionnaire response log maintained and reconciled annually against the report.
- Supplier data program cycle initiated — Q4.
- Contractual deliverable calendar maintained — ongoing. [LIABILITY]
12. Incident response
- Prior-year data error: materiality assessed; restatement policy applied; change described clearly; prior statements assessed for correction. A silently changed figure is worse than the original error.
- Target expected to be missed: disclosure updated when the internal view changes, not at the deadline. [LIABILITY]
- Marketing claim challenged: substantiation pulled; claim stopped immediately if support is inadequate.
- Methodology change that improves the figure: change management policy applied; effect quantified separately and disclosed.
- Acquisition or divestiture: base year recalculation applied and disclosed.
- Litigation hold considered for inventory records, target analyses, and internal assessments.
13. Transaction diligence (buying or selling)
- Existing inventory and methodology reviewed.
- Assurance history and findings reviewed.
- Live environmental marketing claims and their substantiation reviewed. [LIABILITY]
- Contractual sustainability commitments identified, including credit agreement KPIs and customer obligations.
- Regulatory filings reviewed for accuracy and completeness.
- Pending or threatened greenwashing claims identified.
- Sustainability representations and indemnities negotiated.
- Post-closing base year recalculation planned.
Related documents
- Climate and Sustainability Disclosure: What Companies Report and to Whom
- Building a Sustainability Disclosure Program: A Practical Guide
- Sustainability Reporting Toolkit: Governance, Data Controls, and Assurance
- Public Company Disclosure: Periodic Reports, Regulation FD, and Insider Trading Liability
- False Advertising Claim Checklist: A Practical Checklist
- Fiduciary Duties of Directors and Officers: The Business Judgment Rule, Loyalty, and Caremark Oversight
This checklist is general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
