Document type: Checklist Practice area: Corporate — Mergers and Acquisitions Jurisdiction: United States (Delaware and federal) Last reviewed: 5 September 2026


How to use this checklist

Sections 1 through 7 are drafting. Sections 8 and 9 are administration and run from closing through final payment. Section 10 is the dispute path.

Items marked [HIGH VALUE] are the ones that most often decide the outcome, and the ones most often left out of a first draft.


1. Threshold: should there be an earnout?

  • The contingency identified: what specifically is uncertain?
  • The contingency is binary and verifiable, or it is not — recorded either way.
  • The contingency is within or outside the buyer's control — recorded.
  • Whether the target will be operated standalone or integrated immediately.
  • Whether seller management will remain through the earnout period.
  • Alternatives considered and rejected on the record: lower fixed price; seller note; rollover equity; holdback; representation and warranty insurance.
  • Seller advised, in writing, that an earnout is a contingent claim against a company it will not control, measured by numbers it will not prepare. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Probability-weighted present value of the earnout modeled and shown to the client. [HIGH VALUE]


2. Letter of intent

  • Metric named (binary event / revenue / gross profit / EBITDA / net income).
  • Measurement period stated.
  • Payout structure stated as linear or tiered between a floor and a cap — not a cliff. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Cumulative measurement (shortfalls recoverable from later outperformance) stated.
  • Acceleration on sale, discontinuation, and covenant breach stated in principle. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Operating covenants flagged by category.
  • Security flagged — at minimum a parent guarantee.
  • Buyer's reservation of operating discretion (subject to agreed covenants) stated.

3. Defining the earnout metric

  • "Business" defined by product SKU and contract, not by legal entity or business unit. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Successor, derivative, and replacement products expressly included.
  • Revenue attribution follows the product sold, not the entity or sales organization that books it. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Bundle allocation methodology stated (standalone list price basis or other).
  • Intercompany transfer price for Business products stated.
  • If EBITDA or below: overhead allocation capped in dollars, with an escalator. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Overhead exclusion list: corporate development, investor relations, treasury, internal audit, buyer-wide systems implementations, buyer's other acquisitions, buyer management fees.
  • Metric exclusions: purchase accounting effects; transaction expenses; non-cash stock compensation; transaction-created goodwill impairment; buyer-driven restructuring charges.
  • Treatment of revenue recognition policy changes — prohibited or neutralized.
  • Treatment of acquisitions and dispositions by the Business during the period.
  • Currency and conversion mechanism if cross-border.

4. Sample calculation and accounting hierarchy

  • Sample calculation prepared using the target's most recent full fiscal year and actual trial balance. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Every definition and exclusion applied in the sample calculation.
  • Both sides' accountants have agreed the arithmetic.
  • Sample calculation attached as a signed exhibit.
  • Accounting hierarchy stated in three tiers: (1) agreed policies exhibit; (2) historical practice consistently applied; (3) GAAP. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Anti-restatement covenant included: no change in reserves, accruals, estimates, or judgments except where underlying facts changed; no methodology not used in the sample calculation.
  • Confirmation that both sides' systems can actually produce the metric.

5. Operating covenants and buyer discretion

  • Separate books and records for the Business, prepared consistently with the sample calculation.
  • Minimum dedicated sales headcount stated numerically.
  • Minimum marketing spend stated as a percentage of revenue or a dollar floor.
  • No discontinuation or cessation of support for scheduled products without consent.
  • Pricing change limits with a consultation requirement.
  • No reassignment of scheduled customer accounts away from the Business organization.
  • Treatment no less favorable than comparable buyer products in channels, incentive plans, and marketing.
  • No change to revenue recognition policy for the metric.
  • Retention of named key employees other than for Cause.
  • Effects-based backstop covenant that does not turn on intent. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Buyer discretion clause, expressly subject to the covenants.
  • Efforts language deleted or, if retained, supplemented with numeric floors.

6. Acceleration, security, and set-off

  • Acceleration events enumerated: sale of the Business; discontinuation above a stated threshold; uncured covenant breach; change of control without written assumption; key employee termination without Cause; insolvency. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Acceleration payment amount stated (maximum remaining earnout, or a formula).
  • Obligor identified by name and its creditworthiness assessed.
  • Parent guarantee obtained. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Escrow or letter of credit considered and priced.
  • Negative covenants at the obligor level considered (distributions, additional indebtedness).
  • Set-off limited to finally determined claims, or disputed amounts escrowed rather than retained. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Order of recourse specified among adjustment escrow, indemnity escrow, insurance, earnout, and seller recourse.

7. Purchase price adjustment mechanics

Components

  • Line-item schedule prepared from the trial balance; every account designated as working capital, cash, indebtedness, transaction expense, or excluded. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Deferred revenue treatment resolved: in or out; at face or at cost to fulfil.
  • Income tax accounts resolved.
  • Accrued bonuses and vacation treatment resolved.
  • Intercompany balances eliminated expressly.
  • Current portion of long-term debt placed in indebtedness and not double-counted. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Prepaid expenses, including insurance to be cancelled at closing.
  • Inventory reserve methodology stated.
  • Cash defined: gross or net of outstanding checks; restricted cash; foreign cash and repatriation cost.
  • Indebtedness defined by list, including capital leases, deferred purchase price from prior acquisitions, accrued interest, prepayment penalties and breakage, underfunded pension, related-party loans, and drawn letters of credit.
  • Transaction expenses defined by list, including employer payroll taxes on transaction bonuses and change-of-control payments. [HIGH VALUE]

Target and mechanics

  • Working capital target computed from the same schedule and methodology as the closing statement. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Seasonality adjustment considered.
  • Two-way or one-way adjustment stated.
  • Collar stated as a true deductible or a true threshold, and identified as which.
  • Adjustment escrow funded, separate from the indemnity escrow.
  • Escrow release automatic on finalization.
  • Same accounting hierarchy and anti-restatement covenant applied.

8. Dispute mechanism design

  • Preparation period stated; preparing party identified.
  • Access provision enumerating: books and records; work papers; buyer consolidation entries; cost allocation schedules and supporting detail; intercompany pricing records; management reporting packages; SKU-level revenue detail; headcount and marketing spend data. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Objection period stated, and starting on delivery of access, not on delivery of the statement. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Deemed acceptance consequence stated.
  • Objection specificity requirement stated; consequence for unobjected items stated.
  • Negotiation period before submission.
  • Independent accountant named, with a nomination fallback and a default appointment mechanism.
  • Conflicts screening required before appointment.
  • Scope limited to disputed items only.
  • Baseball resolution required (accountant must select one party's position per item). [HIGH VALUE]
  • Governing standard stated as the agreement's hierarchy and the sample calculation, not the accountant's preference.
  • Procedure stated: simultaneous written submissions, page limits, one response round, no ex parte contact, determination deadline.
  • Fees allocated in proportion to amounts decided against each party.
  • Expert or arbitrator status stated expressly — determining whether 9 U.S.C. § 9 confirmation and § 10 vacatur review apply. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Breach claims expressly carved out of the accountant's jurisdiction and routed to litigation or arbitration. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Accountant instruction letter drafted as an exhibit at signing.

9. Seller representative and allocation

  • Representative appointed by name in the agreement and in the letters of transmittal.
  • Irrevocable power of attorney binding successors and assigns.
  • Authority granted: receive notices, object, negotiate, settle, engage professionals, bind sellers, allocate and distribute.
  • Expense fund withheld at closing, replenishable, returnable at termination. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Exculpation and indemnity from sellers.
  • Professional representative firm considered where sellers are numerous.
  • Allocation spreadsheet prepared and attached at closing, covering preferences, participation, option holders, and non-signing holders. [HIGH VALUE]

10. Administration

Buyer, from day one

  • Reporting unit created and general ledger configured to produce the metric per the sample calculation. [HIGH VALUE]
  • One-page operating covenant summary circulated to integration, sales, finance, and product leadership. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Quarterly covenant compliance record maintained: headcount, marketing spend, product continuity, account assignments, pricing.
  • Business decisions affecting the metric documented with contemporaneous independent rationale.
  • Internal communications discipline briefed.
  • Statement delivered on time, tied line by line to the sample calculation, with supporting schedules.
  • Voluntary interim information provided to the seller representative.

Seller representative, when a statement arrives

  • Objection deadline and all intermediate dates calendared the same day. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Written access request sent the same day, listing categories specifically. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Accountant with earnout dispute experience engaged.
  • Statement tied line by line to the sample calculation.
  • Overhead allocation tested against the cap and the exclusion list.
  • Revenue attribution tested at SKU level.
  • Exclusions tested.
  • Covenant compliance tested separately from the accounting.
  • Objection notice objects to every item with any basis — withdrawal is possible later, addition is not. [HIGH VALUE]

11. Tax

  • Installment method under 26 U.S.C. § 453 applied, or election out made deliberately.
  • Contingent payment basis recovery method determined.
  • Imputed interest computed under 26 U.S.C. § 483 and, for debt instruments, 26 U.S.C. § 1274.
  • Whether the earnout bears stated interest, and at what rate, addressed in the agreement.
  • Purchase price separated from employment compensation — earnout not conditioned on continued employment; separate market-rate employment agreement. [HIGH VALUE]
  • Consideration allocation among asset classes addressed and updated as payments are made.
  • Buyer and seller reporting positions agreed at signing to avoid inconsistency.
  • Withholding and gross-up addressed if cross-border.

12. Dispute path

  • Claim characterized correctly: express covenant breach; accounting dispute; implied covenant.
  • Implied covenant claim assessed against its limits — it fills gaps and does not override express terms.
  • Contractual deadlines confirmed met.
  • Discovery targets identified: integration plans, budgets and variances, sales compensation plans, channel policies, management reporting packages, board materials, accounting work papers.
  • Counterfactual damages model built with an expert.
  • Acceleration claim asserted where available, in preference to a damages claim.
  • Employment consequences for seller principals still employed considered and addressed.
  • Settlement posture assessed against the cost of a multi-year dispute over a contingent sum.

Related documents


This checklist is general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.