Summary. A working kit: a remedy comparison, worksheets for inventory, eligibility, and which barrier actually matters, the filings, the seven post-order letters, the consumer law instruments, licensing and pardon documents, and the authorities.
SECTION A — WHICH REMEDY DOES WHAT
| Remedy | Record destroyed? | Public access | May you deny it? | Restores firearms? | Helps immigration? | Typical availability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Expungement | Rarely — most statutes seal | Removed | Often, per statute — read it | Depends on the state provision's exact text (§ 921(a)(20)) | Generally no if rehabilitative | Waiting period; category limits |
| Sealing | No | Removed from public; available to law enforcement, courts, some licensors and employers | Sometimes | Usually no | No | Broader than expungement |
| Set aside / vacatur (rehabilitative) | No | Usually still visible | Sometimes | Sometimes | No | After probation completion |
| Vacatur for a legal defect | No | Still visible | No | Depends | YES — this is the one that works | Requires a defect: Padilla, Brady, involuntary plea |
| Certificate of relief | No | Fully public | No | No | No | Often available where expungement is not; lifts specific licensing bars; negligent-hiring presumption in several states |
| Pardon | No | Public | Usually not | Often yes | Limited | Discretionary; long waits; rare |
| Clean slate (automatic) | No | Sealed automatically | Per statute | No | No | No petition, no fee — but does not reach commercial databases |
| Diversion / deferred adjudication | N/A — no conviction | Case dismissed | Usually yes | N/A | Best outcome, though "conviction" is defined broadly for immigration | Only available while the case is open |
SECTION B — WORKSHEETS
B-1. Record inventory
| # | County / court | Case no. | Arrest date | Charges as filed | Charges as resolved | Disposition | Date | Sentence | Balance owed | Certified disposition obtained? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ☐ | |||||||||
| 2 | ☐ |
Sources to check, all of them: state repository (complete version) · FBI identity history summary · county dockets in every county lived in · municipal courts (frequently unreported) · a commercial background check on yourself.
B-2. Eligibility analysis (one per case)
CASE ____________________ Offense: ______________________
Disposition: ____________ Date: ________ Sentence ended: ________
□ OFFENSE CATEGORY
Excluded by statute? □ No □ Yes — which exclusion: ____________
(Common: violent felony · registrable sex offense · offense against
a child · DUI)
□ WAITING PERIOD
Statute measures from: □ conviction □ sentence completion
□ probation completion
Required: ____ years. Elapsed: ____ years ____ months. □ Met
□ CONVICTION-FREE PERIOD
Required: ____ years. Any new offenses? ______ □ Met
Pending charges now? ______
□ SENTENCE COMPLETE
Probation ☐ Community service ☐ Treatment ☐
FINANCIAL OBLIGATIONS: $________ still owed ← MOST COMMON BAR
□ NUMBER LIMITS
Total convictions: ____ Statute allows: ____
Do ALL convictions count toward eligibility for ANY? ______
Lifetime cap on records cleared? ______
□ NATURE OF RELIEF □ Mandatory □ Discretionary
CONCLUSION: □ Eligible now □ Eligible on ________
□ Not eligible → certificate / pardon / post-conviction
B-3. Collateral consequences inventory — which barrier is actually costing you?
| Barrier | Applies? | Evidence | Which remedy addresses it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Job denial | Adverse action notice; report | FCRA dispute · fair chance individualized assessment · expungement | |
| Licensing bar | Denial letter; board statute | Certificate of relief · preliminary determination · expungement | |
| Housing denial | Screening report; denial | FCRA dispute · sealing · fair housing (blanket exclusions) | |
| Firearm prohibition | State restoration + § 921(a)(20) analysis · pardon | ||
| Voting | Restoration statute; pay/convert outstanding obligations | ||
| Immigration | NTA; charging document | Vacatur for a legal defect — NOT rehabilitative expungement | |
| Public benefits / housing assistance | Category-specific; often waivable | ||
| Custody / adoption / foster licensing | Certificate; time; documentation | ||
| Internet / mugshot | Search results | Removal demands; de-indexing; editor requests |
Diagnose before choosing the tool. The strongest-sounding remedy is frequently not the useful one.
SECTION C — FILINGS
C-1. Motion to waive, convert, or plan court costs
MOTION TO WAIVE, REMIT, OR CONVERT FINANCIAL OBLIGATIONS
Defendant moves to waive or remit the outstanding balance of $______ in fines, fees, and costs in this matter, or in the alternative to convert the balance to community service or to establish a payment plan based on ability to pay, and states:
- Judgment entered on [date]. The original assessment was $; the current balance, including interest and surcharges, is $ (statement attached).
- Defendant's monthly income is $______ and monthly necessary expenses are $______ (financial affidavit attached). Defendant [receives ______ public benefits / is unemployed / supports ____ dependents].
- Defendant is unable to pay the balance without depriving [himself/herself/themselves] and dependents of basic necessities.
- Under [statute/rule ], this Court may waive or remit costs, convert them to community service at a credit of $_ per hour, or establish a payment plan proportioned to income.
- The outstanding balance is presently the sole barrier to Defendant's eligibility for [expungement / sealing / restoration of voting rights] under [statute ___].
WHEREFORE Defendant requests waiver or remission; alternatively conversion at a stated hourly credit; alternatively an income-based payment plan; and remission of accrued interest and surcharges.
[Attach: financial affidavit · benefits verification · pay records or proof of unemployment · current balance statement.]
C-2. Petition for expungement / sealing — outline
PETITION FOR [EXPUNGEMENT / SEALING] OF CRIMINAL RECORDS
1. Petitioner's full name, any former names, DOB, and address.
2. The case: county, court, case number, arrest date, arresting agency.
3. Charges as filed; charges as resolved; disposition and date.
4. Sentence imposed and the date it was completed in full.
5. All financial obligations satisfied on [date] (receipt attached).
6. No convictions since [date]; no charges pending (current criminal
history attached).
7. The offense is not excluded under [statute § ___].
8. The waiting period of ____ years under [statute § ___] expired on
[date].
9. [DISCRETIONARY STATUTES] Relief is consistent with the public
interest for the reasons stated in the attached Statement.
10. Notice has been served on the prosecuting attorney [and the victim
as required by § ___].
WHEREFORE Petitioner requests an order [expunging/sealing] all records
of this case, including records held by the arresting agency, the
clerk, the prosecuting attorney, the [jail], and the state central
repository, and directing that the record be removed from public
access and from any online docket.
EXHIBITS: A certified disposition · B current criminal history ·
C proof of financial satisfaction · D personal statement ·
E support letters · F documentation of the barrier
C-3. Personal statement template (for discretionary petitions)
STATEMENT OF PETITIONER
What happened. In [month, year], when I was [age], I [state the offense in plain, accurate terms — the same terms the file uses]. I [pleaded guilty / was convicted] on [date] and was sentenced to [sentence]. I completed [probation / the sentence] on [date] and paid all fines and costs in full on [date].
What I have done since. [Employment, with employers and dates. Education or training completed, with dates. Treatment or programs completed. Military service. Caregiving. Community involvement. Be specific and verifiable.]
Why I am asking now. [The concrete barrier, documented.] On [date], [the Board of ___ denied my application / an offer of employment as ___ was withdrawn / I was denied housing at ___] solely because of this record. The denial letter is attached as Exhibit ___. I completed [training/program] in [month, year] and cannot [work in the field I trained for / house my family].
What I understand. [Three or four sentences, in your own words, without excuses and without re-litigating the case. Judges are deciding whether you are the same person who committed the offense; minimizing it answers that badly.]
[Signature and date]
C-4. Support letter template (give this to each writer)
To the writer: a general character reference is worth little. What persuades is specific, observed conduct, with dates, from someone identified by role. Please keep it to one page.
[Letterhead if available] · [Date]
To the Honorable Judge of the [Court]:
My name is [name] and I am [role — supervisor, employer, pastor, counselor, coach] at [organization]. I have known [petitioner] since [month, year], in the following capacity: [describe].
What I have observed. [Specific and dated. "She has worked as a shift supervisor since March 2022, has not missed a scheduled shift, and was promoted in January 2024 to train new employees." Not "she is a good person."]
Why I am writing. I understand [petitioner] is asking the Court to [seal/expunge] a record from [year]. [If you know about the offense, say that you do — a letter from someone who does not know is worth less.] Based on what I have seen over [duration], [describe the judgment you are offering].
[Signature · printed name · title · telephone]
SECTION D — AFTER THE ORDER: THE SEVEN LETTERS
D-1. Master cover letter (adapt the addressee for each)
Re: [Name], DOB [] · Order of [Expungement / Sealing] entered [date] · [Court], Case No. []
Enclosed is a certified copy of an order entered on [date] [expunging / sealing] the records of the above matter.
I request that your agency: (1) update, seal, or remove the corresponding record in your files and in any database to which you report; (2) cease disseminating the record to any person or entity; (3) notify any entity to which you previously disseminated it; and (4) provide me with written confirmation that this has been completed.
My identifiers are: [full name · any former names · DOB · SSN last four · state ID number · arrest date and arresting agency · case number].
Please respond within [30] days.
[Name · address · telephone]
D-2. The distribution list
□ 1. STATE CRIMINAL HISTORY REPOSITORY → request written confirmation
□ 2. FBI (CJIS) → if the case appears on your identity history summary
□ 3. ARRESTING AGENCY → maintains its own local record
□ 4. COURT CLERK → docket sealed AND removed from public terminals
and the online case search
□ 5. PROSECUTING ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
□ 6. JAIL / DETENTION FACILITY → booking record and PHOTOGRAPH
□ 7. EVERY BACKGROUND CHECK COMPANY IDENTIFIED
(start with the one whose report you obtained)
FOR EACH: certified copy · cover letter · PROOF OF DELIVERY retained
FOLLOW UP: 45 days
VERIFY: re-run a background check on yourself at 90 days
SECTION E — CONSUMER LAW INSTRUMENTS
E-1. FCRA dispute letter
Re: Dispute of inaccurate information — [Name], DOB [] · Report No. [] dated [__]
I dispute the following item(s) in the above consumer report:
Item 1. [As reported:] "[quote exactly]." This is inaccurate. The case, [court and case number], was dismissed on [date]. A certified disposition is enclosed. [Or: The record was sealed by order entered [date]; a certified copy is enclosed. Or: This record does not belong to me; my identifiers are [] and the record reflects [].]
Item 2. [Repeat.]
Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681i you must conduct a reasonable reinvestigation and delete or modify information that is inaccurate, incomplete, or cannot be verified, generally within 30 days. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681e(b) you must follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681c, records of arrest that did not result in conviction may not be reported after seven years.
Please send me the results of the reinvestigation and a corrected report, and provide notice of the correction to every person who received a report containing this information in the past [six months / two years for employment purposes].
Enclosed: certified disposition(s) · order of [expungement/sealing] · copy of the report with items circled · identification.
[Send traceably. Send the same letter to the furnisher.]
E-2. Response to a pre-adverse action notice
Re: Conditional offer for [position] · Pre-adverse action notice dated [__]
Thank you for providing the consumer report and the summary of rights. The report contains errors, and I am disputing them.
- The report shows [case] as "pending." It was dismissed on [date]. The certified disposition is enclosed.
- The report shows [case]. That record was sealed by court order on [date] and should not have been reported. A certified copy of the order is enclosed.
- The report shows [case], which is not mine. [Identifiers.]
I have filed a dispute with [agency] today, a copy of which is enclosed. I respectfully ask that you hold the decision until the reinvestigation is complete, which the agency must generally conduct within 30 days.
I am glad to discuss any accurate item in the report. [If applicable: The [year] conviction is accurate. I completed my sentence in [year], have had no further contact with the criminal system, and have worked at [employer] since [year]; my supervisor [name] is available at [number].]
E-3. Mugshot / arrest-site removal demand
Re: Demand for removal — [Name] · URL: [__]
Your site publishes a booking photograph and arrest information concerning me at the URL above. The charge was [dismissed / resolved by acquittal] on [date], and [the record was sealed/expunged by order entered [date]]. Certified copies are enclosed.
I demand that the page and image be removed within [10] days and that you cease republishing this information.
[Where applicable:] [State statute § ___] prohibits requiring payment for removal of such content and requires removal on receipt of proof of [dismissal/sealing], and provides for [statutory damages / injunctive relief / attorney's fees] for non-compliance. I will not pay any fee for removal.
Please confirm removal in writing.
SECTION F — LICENSING AND CLEMENCY
F-1. Preliminary determination request
Re: Request for a preliminary determination — [Board]
I intend to pursue licensure as a [profession] and am considering enrolling in [program], which requires [duration] and costs approximately $[amount]. Before making that commitment, I request a preliminary determination under [statute § ___] as to whether my criminal history disqualifies me.
My history: [offense], [court], convicted [date], sentence completed [date], no subsequent offenses. A certified disposition and a current criminal history are enclosed.
Since then I have [employment, training, treatment, with dates].
Please advise whether this history would be a bar, whether it would be considered under a direct-relationship standard, and what evidence of rehabilitation the Board considers.
F-2. Pardon application — outline
1. IDENTIFYING INFORMATION and complete criminal history — ALL of it.
(Omitting anything is fatal; the office will find it.)
2. THE OFFENSE: what happened, in accurate terms, without excuses.
3. SENTENCE and the date it was completed in full.
4. TIME ELAPSED since completion: ____ years. (Most jurisdictions
impose a multi-year minimum by rule.)
5. RESPONSIBILITY: a short statement in your own words.
6. REHABILITATION: employment history with dates · education · training
· treatment · military service · community involvement · caregiving.
7. THE SPECIFIC NEED: what the pardon would allow that is otherwise
foreclosed (licensing, firearms, adoption, travel, employment).
8. LETTERS of support — specific, dated, from people who know about
the offense.
9. VICTIM considerations, addressed honestly.
10. ATTACHMENTS: certified dispositions · current criminal history ·
proof of financial satisfaction · documentation of the barrier.
⚠ A pardon generally does NOT erase the record. Some states permit
expungement following a pardon — check.
SECTION G — PRIMARY AUTHORITY
- 15 U.S.C. § 1681c — FCRA limits on reporting non-conviction arrests and other adverse items, and the salary threshold exception.
- 18 U.S.C. § 921(a)(20) — the effect of pardon, expungement, and restoration of civil rights on federal firearm disability.
- 18 U.S.C. § 922 — the prohibitions; 18 U.S.C. § 925(c) — relief from disabilities.
- 18 U.S.C. § 3607 — the narrow federal expungement for first-offense simple possession by a person under 21.
- 42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2 — Title VII, the basis for disparate impact challenges to blanket criminal history exclusions.
- Bearden v. Georgia, 461 U.S. 660 (1983) — ability to pay must be considered before punishing non-payment.
- The Second Chance Act, 34 U.S.C. § 60501 et seq.; the INA definition of "conviction," 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(48); state expungement, sealing, certificate of relief, clean slate, ban-the-box, fair chance, occupational licensing reform, and mugshot removal statutes.
Related documents
- Expungement, Record Sealing, and Restoring Rights After a Conviction
- Clearing Your Criminal Record
- Expungement and Record Relief Checklist
- Criminal Defense Toolkit
- DUI Defense Toolkit
- Consumer Debt Defense Toolkit
- Landlord-Tenant Toolkit
This toolkit is educational and not legal advice. Every form must be adapted to state law; eligibility, procedure, and effect vary enormously. If you are not a U.S. citizen, consult immigration counsel before filing anything.