Discipline

Labor and Employment | Management

We advise employers on employee discipline including performance management, progressive discipline, documentation practices, and termination decisions to minimize legal exposure.

Overview

Managing Employee Performance and Conduct

Effective discipline is essential to workplace management but creates legal exposure when handled poorly. MC Law's Discipline practice helps employers address performance and conduct issues while minimizing legal risk.

Progressive Discipline

Progressive discipline systems support fair treatment and legal compliance. We design progressive discipline frameworks, advise on appropriate steps, and help ensure consistent application.

Documentation Proper documentation supports discipline decisions. We train managers on effective documentation practices, review documentation for legal sufficiency, and advise on creating defensible records. Performance Management Performance problems require careful handling. We advise on performance improvement plans, coaching documentation, and performance-based terminations. We help managers address performance constructively. Conduct Issues Misconduct requires appropriate response. We advise on investigation of conduct issues, proportionate discipline, and termination for cause. We help employers respond appropriately to policy violations. Consistency Inconsistent discipline creates legal exposure. We advise on achieving consistent treatment across managers and locations. We develop frameworks that promote consistency while allowing appropriate discretion. Pre-Termination Review Termination decisions benefit from legal review. We evaluate termination recommendations, identify legal risks, and advise on appropriate process. We help employers make defensible termination decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Progressive discipline is a structured approach that escalates consequences for repeated misconduct—typically verbal warning, written warning, suspension, and termination. While not legally required in at-will employment, it provides consistency and documentation that supports termination decisions.

Serious misconduct such as violence, theft, harassment, safety violations, or gross insubordination typically justifies immediate termination without progressive steps. Policies should reserve the right to skip steps based on the severity of the offense.

Documentation should include the specific behavior or performance issue, the policy or standard violated, prior warnings or counseling, the employee's response, corrective actions required, and consequences of continued issues. Consistency across employees is essential.

Risks include discrimination claims if discipline is applied inconsistently across protected groups, retaliation claims if discipline follows protected activity, wrongful discharge claims, and defamation claims from communications about the discipline.

Yes, allowing employees to provide their perspective demonstrates fairness and creates a more complete record. Employee responses should be documented and considered, even if the employer ultimately proceeds with the disciplinary action.

Fair use is a defense that permits limited use of copyrighted material without permission. Courts consider four factors: the purpose and character of use (commercial vs. educational, transformative vs. copying), the nature of the copyrighted work, the amount used, and the effect on the market. Fair use is highly fact-specific.

For works created today by individual authors, copyright lasts for the life of the author plus 70 years. Works made for hire and anonymous/pseudonymous works are protected for 95 years from publication or 120 years from creation, whichever is shorter. Older works may have different terms.

Yes, software code is protected by copyright as a literary work. Both source code and object code can be registered. However, copyright protects the expression of ideas, not the underlying functionality—patent protection may be more appropriate for novel methods and processes implemented in software.

Our virtual legal services offer streamlined, cost-effective solutions for common copyright needs. Services like copyright registration, assignment agreements, and DMCA takedowns are available online with fixed, transparent pricing. You get the quality of a top IP firm with the convenience of digital delivery.

Related Matters

StreamCo v. ContentPirate Networks

Represented streaming platform in landmark DMCA safe harbor case. Successfully defended client's safe harbor status while obtaining injunctive relief against repeat infringers, resulting in dismissal of $500M damages claim.

Venue: C.D. Cal.Result: Favorable Settlement
PhotoArt LLC v. Social Media Giant

Prosecuted copyright infringement claims on behalf of professional photographers whose work was used without authorization. Secured significant damages award and implementation of improved licensing procedures.

Venue: S.D.N.Y.Result: $2.4M Judgment
GameDev Studios v. CopyCat Apps

Enforced copyright and trade dress rights in mobile game against clone applications. Obtained preliminary injunction and permanent removal of infringing apps from major app stores worldwide.

Venue: N.D. Cal.Result: Preliminary Injunction
MusicPublisher Inc. v. AI Training Corp

Cutting-edge case addressing use of copyrighted music in AI training datasets. Negotiated comprehensive licensing framework that allows continued AI development while protecting rightsholders' interests.

Venue: D. Del.Result: Licensing Agreement
SoftwareCo v. Former CTO

Prosecuted claims against former executive who copied proprietary source code to competitor. Established ownership under work-for-hire doctrine and obtained injunction plus damages for willful infringement.

Venue: E.D. Tex.Result: Summary Judgment
University Press v. Document Sharing Site

Represented academic publisher in enforcement action against site hosting pirated textbooks. Implemented systematic takedown program and pursued contributory infringement claims against operators.

Venue: D. Mass.Result: Default Judgment

Get in Touch

Connect with our copyright team to discuss your matter

Send Us a Message