CorporateCorporate Governance
Fiduciary Duties of Directors and Officers: The Business Judgment Rule, Loyalty, and Caremark Oversight
Directors are not liable for bad outcomes, and that single sentence explains most of what the law of fiduciary duty does. The business judgment rule presumes that a disinterested, informed, good-faith board decision was proper, and the entire architecture of corporate litigation is built around whether a plaintiff can knock that presumption down. This article works through the three duties that matter — care, loyalty, and the oversight obligation that grew out of Caremark — and shows where each one actually breaks in practice: uninformed sale processes, conflicted transactions that skipped a cleansing procedure, and compliance systems that never existed for a risk central to the business. It also covers exculpation, indemnification, advancement, and D&O coverage, the protections that determine whether a breach finding costs a director money or costs an insurer money, and it addresses closely held companies and LLCs, where the rules differ in ways that surprise people who learned them from public-company cases.